“The play’s climax is a parade led by a drummer, Kelsey Elizabeth Holley, and accented by that Ayler-esque saxophonist, who turned out to be the real thing and named Anthony Leung. Behind them, prisoners-shackled, numbered and masked to look like owls, plague doctors, capped dunces-march through the crowd. ”
— From Aaron Tomey of Grimesquare, Blood on the Ground in the Dark; On Stairwells Theater's production of Caryl Churchill's 'Far Away' (Box of Moonlight, Bushwick)
“Keely Bierne as Anita is quite a solid character, and together with Kelsey Elisabeth Holley (Consuelo) and the rest of the Sharks girls provide the much-needed comic relief, lest the show tips to a depressing rut. Holley is funny and smart, her antics will get you floored every time. And oh, that blonde wig! Don’t say I didn’t warn you.”
— From Vince Vicentuan of Broadwayworld Philippines; Review: West Side Story, a Classic Through and Through (The Theatre at Solaria, Manila)
“...and Kelsey Elisabeth Holley’s bleach blond Consuelo not only dances evocatively but acts convincingly as one of the Shark girls.”
— From Michael Hooper, The Search for a new way of Living continues, Review of West Side Story (The Civic theatre, Aukland, NZ)
“...it was interesting to see the Jets and Sharks working together to create a solid moment that went perfectly with Kelsey Elisabeth Holley’s soothing, soaring voice as Consuelo.”
— From Bakchormeeboy; Review: West Side Story by BASE Entertainment Asia (Mastercard Theatres at Marina Bay Sands, Singapore)
